Skip to main content

Table 2 Quantitative results

From: Lung nodule malignancy classification with associated pulmonary fibrosis using 3D attention-gated convolutional network with CT scans

Dataset

LIDC-IDRI

In-house

In-house

Training strategy/data processing

NA

NA

Pretrained on LIDC-IDRI data

Pretrained on LIDC-IDRI data/Nodule surrounding tissues removed

Pretrained on LIDC-IDRI data/semantic fibrosis data added

Micro-environment information

Available

Available

Available

Not available

Available

Accuracy (%)*

85.11 (3.19)

78.84 (5.88)

79.03 (2.97)*

75.61 (7.02)*

80.84 (3.31)*

Sensitivity (%)†

77.78 (12.24)

62.00 (13.65)

65.46 (18.64)†

50.00 (25.46)†

74.67 (14.78)†

Specificity (%)§

88.54 (5.87)

87.29 (5.98)

85.86 (6.29)§

88.46 (7.88)§

84.95 (5.43)§

AUC

0.90 (0.04)

0.83 (0.03)

0.84 (0.06)

0.78 (0.08)

0.89 (0.05)

  1. Data are presented in the format of Mean (Standard deviation), AUC area under the receiver operating characteristic
  2. *One-way ANOVA analysis performed with Bonferroni correction on accuracy: p-value = 0.0011 (statistical significance)
  3. †One-way ANOVA analysis performed with Bonferroni correction on sensitivity: p-value = 0.0013 (statistical significance)
  4. §One-way ANOVA analysis performed with Bonferroni correction on specificity p-value = 0.35556 (statistical non-significance)